The War at Home
The Students will be able to analyze political cartoons about a variety of citizens of South Carolina during the Reconstruction Period while noting the social class, race, gender, and age differences within the political cartoons in order to gain the skill to create their own political cartoon.
Lesson Created By: Mary Huffman
Essential Question
How did the Civil War impact South Carolinians of various social classes including those groups defined by race, gender, and age as noted in political cartoons created during the Civil War era?
Grade(s):
- 8
Subject(s):
Recommended Technology:
SCETV videos
iPads/Computers/Tablets to access the political cartoons instead of printing off the political cartoons to analyze
iPad app Strip Design, Comic Book, or Comics Head to help students create a political cartoon
Other Instructional Materials or Notes:
- Dry erase markers (1 per pair of students)
- White copy paper for the students to create their own political cartoons
- Fact/inference graphic organizer
- A copy of the SC Support Documents for 8-4.6
Lesson Progression
Day 1
Review prior knowledge about major events leading up to and through the Civil War. Discuss these events using detail from prior classes to support their answers.
Anticipatory: Show a short video clip reviewing political cartoons and how to analyze them. Political cartoons have been used for hundreds of years. Analysis of political cartoons is very rigorous and takes not only knowledge of history, but also inferring skills related to reading.
Direct Instruction: Show a PowerPoint presentation describing techniques used to analyze political cartoons. One strategy might be to use quadrants in order to pick out the details in the four regions of the political cartoon.
- Make a plus sign on the political cartoon.
- Complete a graphic organizer listing in the facts column everything that can be seen directly in the cartoon such as important people, items in their hands, and the setting. Complete the inference section of the graphic organizer to list all predictions based on the cartoon such as why the people are in the setting. Model how to do this with one of the attached political cartoons.
Guided practice: The students will analyze a political cartoon from the Civil War period including white women, African American slaves, rich plantation owners, poor southerners, children, and freed African Americans. Laminate the political cartoons and give the students a dry erase marker to draw the plus sign on the document. Then circle with the marker people and items that can be seen in each of the quadrants. List these items on their graphic organizer labeled facts. Then on the inference side, list all the predictions that can be made about the political cartoon including the time period in history, Why were the people in the setting? What were they doing in that part of history? What’s the author’s purpose for writing the cartoon? How did the author’s perspective effect the cartoon?
Independent Practice: Making Political Cartoons
- Pass out white copy paper to each student and have them choose a different person from the guided practice lesson of the lesson during the Civil War period including white women, African American slaves, rich plantation owners, poor southerners, children, and freed African Americans.Then students need to determine the social class, race, and gender of the person/people in their cartoon. Using prior knowledge and the SC Support Documents, create a political cartoon depicting life for the person of their choice during the Civil War.
- Ten specific facts and inferences should be able to be made about the cartoon. This will only be a rough draft so focus more on the symbols instead of the drawing.
- After about 15 minutes, swap the student's’ rough draft with a partner in the class. Pass out a fact/inference graphic organizer. Students will complete the graphic organizer about their classmates’ political cartoon. If the classmate can’t fill out the chart, then the designer knows that there must be more elements added during the final copy.
For homework, the rough draft and fact/inference graphic organizer is taken home along with a new piece of copy paper. The rough draft is modified and then brought into class the next day. If students have iPads that they can take home or have access to at their house, they can use iPad app Strip Design, Comic Book, or Comics Head to help them create the final copy of their political cartoon.
Day 2
Final copy of political cartoon
Students will swap their final copy with a classmate and they will receive a fact/inference graphic organizer to complete. Their partner should be a new partner with a fresh look at the cartoon.
The graphic organizer and the political cartoon should be stapled together and turned in for an informal assessment grade.
Teacher Notes
Extensions/Differentiation:
High: Students who are higher can be given the opportunity to create additional inferences for their political cartoon.
Low: Students can review all the political cartoon samples provided by the teacher if they are stumped on what to develop in their own cartoon.
"Cartoon America" - Instructional Resource - from the Library of Congress website
A video from the Library of Congress describing political cartoons
View ResourcePolitical cartoons before and during the Civil War printed and laminated - from the Library of Congress website
African American slave and rich plantation owner
View ResourceStrong's dime caricatures. No. 3, South Carolina Topsey in a fix (Uncle Tom's Cabin) - from the Library of Congress website
Antisecessionist print - An elegantly dressed lady, Columbia, is based on Harriet Beecher Stowe's Miss Ophelia, the New England spinster who attempted the moral education of the child.
View ResourceArms of ye Confederacie - from the Library of Congress website
Artist attacks the institution of slavery. A large shield is flanked by two figures: a planter (left) and a slave. The planter wears spurs and a broad-brimmed hat and smokes a cigar.
View ResourceRe-union on the Secesh-Democratic plan - from the Library of Congress website
President of the Confederacy Jefferson Davis confronts Brother Jonathan, who stumbles under the enormous burden of a bundle marked "Confederate Debt $650,000,000" and "Federal Debt $1500,000,000".
View Resource"The freedman's bureau" - Published by Currier & Ives, c1868. Artist: Thomas Worth - from the Library of Congress website
Freed African American
View ResourceThe Freedmen's Bureau / Drawn by A.R. Waud - from the Library of Congress website
Freed African American
View ResourceThe old bull dog on the right track - from the Library of Congress website
President Lincoln and Grant, portrayed as a bulldog wearing a collar labeled "Lieut. General" and epaulets, sits pugnaciously on the tracks of the "Weldon Railroad," a Confederate supply route.
View ResourceStrong's dime caricatures. No. 4, "The schoolmaster abroad" at last - from Library of Congress website
Artist is optimistic about newly elected Abraham Lincoln's ability to end the secession movement among the Southern states.
View ResourceThe folly of secession - from the Library of Congress website
Two parties pulling on the different ends of a cow, while a man in the middle (in this case identified as "Georgia") happily milks the beast.
View ResourceJeff's last skedaddle off to the last ditch - from the Library of Congress website
Depiction of Jefferson Davis
View ResourceThe soldier's song--Unionism vs. Copperheadism - from the Library of Congress website
Union’s beliefs
View ResourceStandards
- 8.3.CO Compare the debates between South Carolina and the federal government regarding slavery, federalism, and the Constitution.
- This indicator was developed to encourage inquiry into the debates, heightened by Westward Expansion, over federal and state power concerning slavery, and the government's role in protecting and securing natural rights.
Assessments
How will students share their work?
The students will collaborate with peers to edit each other’s political cartoon rough draft. Then they will peer-evaluate each other’s political cartoon final copy using the fact/inference graphic organizer. Evaluations/Assessments
You can use the fact/inference graphic organizer as an assessment of the political cartoon that was analyzed by the students on day one. You can also use the fact/inference graphic organizer to evaluate the student's’ final copy of their political cartoon.
Political Cartoon Analysis Sheet
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1YPl5Hw0AyaaHL532qBfxI7kJT6k8kEJhqVNi...